For a Limited Time receive a
FREE HR Report "Top 10 Best Practices in HR Management." This comprehensive special report will give you the information you need to know about these current HR challenges and how to most effectively manage them in your workplace.
Download Now If your workplace is like many, you may have noticed a sudden lack of Scotch
tape, padded envelopes, and scissors during the holiday season.
Even though most workers know that it's wrong to do so, many still filch office
supplies for their personal use. As a corporate "crime," such pilfering is likely
grudgingly viewed by many companies as an annoying fact of life around gift-giving
times.
Yet no matter how innocent it appears to be, theft of company goods and services
is wrong, immoral, and unethical-and sends a signal that a company's ethical
compass may not be aimed true north.
Ethical lapses are widespread
According to a recent survey by the Ethics Officers Association, a nonprofit
organization composed of corporate ethics and compliance officers, in conjunction
with the American Society of Chartered Life Underwriters, half of U.S. workers
have committed one or more illegal or unethical acts in the past year.
These acts included stealing office supplies, abusing sick days, massaging
quality control figures, and using or abusing drugs and alcohol while on company
time. Other types of unethical behavior include:
- Conflicts of interest
- Disclosure of personal or proprietary information
- Inappropriate (giving or receipt of) gifts, favors, and extra compensation
- Bribes, gratuities, or padding of quotes in order to unfairly win a deal
- Use of company equipment for private gain
- Illegal copying of software
- Securities violations such as insider trading
- Deliberately false recordkeeping
- Acts of discrimination
A recent survey by the Society for Human Resource Management (SHRM) echoes
the Ethics Officers Association's findings. Fifty percent of HR managers surveyed
by SHRM have witnessed unethical behavior, and 50 percent have taken part in
unethical behavior. Such wrongful behavior is why businesses across the United
States are developing codes of conduct and ethics and values statements.
Although still more common in health care, financial services, and among government
contractors, the business ethics movement spread more widely across U.S. businesses
during the 1990s. Now, three-quarters of large corporations have a code of conduct
that spells out improper behavior and details the repercussions for ethical
lapses in the workplace.
HR experts and labor and employment attorneys agree that businesses-regardless
of their industry or size-should craft a code of conduct or ethics policy to
ensure that all employees are aware of and understand the basis for making ethical
decisions on the job. Failure to have such a code lays a company open to liability,
should improper behavior occur.
The stakes of ethics
A company's ethical standing clearly must emanate from the top. Therefore,
your senior executives must devoutly believe that righteous behavior is desired,
and, acting as role models, they must strive to always conduct themselves in
an ethical manner. Savvy senior managers are usually quick to embrace an ethics
program, because they know there is a direct correlation between ethical corporate
behavior and a robust bottom line.
They also know that news reports of unethical behavior or illegal activities
can give a business a black eye-among employees, customers, suppliers and vendors,
and influential members of the public-that can't easily be healed. A tarnished
business reputation often is the first step toward business insolvency.
For example, a research and consulting firm noted for its objectivity in its
industry had that reputation temporarily soiled recently. One of its analysts,
in an interview with reporters, touted a particular business as a market leader
without divulging to the news media that she held an ownership position in that
company. When her ownership became public, the analyst was forced to resign
from the firm.
Developing the program and policy
At a recent meeting of the New England Human Resources Association, speakers
included Keith Greene, SPHR, director of organizational programs for SHRM. One
of Greene's specialties is corporate ethics, which he discussed with a workshop
audience. His list of the 10 critical components of a successful ethics program
begins with ethical leadership-the element just discussed.
- Greene urges HR to obtain the highest-level officer possible as the primary
sponsor of an ethics policy. If no one in top management agrees to fill this
role, says Greene, don't let that halt the program. "Do it yourself," he counsels.
- Create ethics vision and values statements for the organization.
- Gather a task force or committee to coordinate the effort.
- Derive a corporate code of ethics from the vision and values statements.
(It's advisable not to give this task to the lawyers but to your managers,
who live and breathe the day-to-day realities of operations. Codes developed
by attorneys tend to be lengthy, full of legal language, and centered on laws
and regulations.) Also, be sure to include lists of acceptable and unacceptable
behavior in such likely problem areas as conflicts of interest, time card
and expense reporting, suppliers and consultants, and company resources and
supplies.
- Name an ethics officer (who Greene feels should be, but doesn't have to
be, the HR director. Making it HR helps to position the function as objectively
balancing advocacy between employees and top management).
- Devise a communications strategy for the program (remembering to distribute
the code and have employees acknowledge receipt and understanding through
their signatures, as well as including a brief description of the code in
interviews with prospective new hires).
- Conduct training, including plenty of sample scenarios. After all, the goal
of the program is to help employees avoid doing something wrong, not to trap
them if and when they do.
- Establish an ethics 'hot line'-preferably one that permits employees to
report suspected misconduct anonymously. Consider making this a service of
your EAP and/or managing it through an outside contractor.
- Develop appropriate rewards for employees who 'do the right thing.'
- Monitor and continually fine-tune your ethical standards.
Mechanisms for reporting and investigating suspected violations are essential,
along with sanctions for violations. These may range from warnings, demotions,
and temporary suspensions to termination and referrals for criminal prosecution,
depending on the severity of the misconduct. If your policy has no teeth, it's
likely to be perceived as a sham.