For a Limited Time receive a
FREE HR Report "Top 10 Best Practices in HR Management." This comprehensive special report will give you the information you need to know about these current HR challenges and how to most effectively manage them in your workplace.
Download Now It's true of most people that if others around them are speaking a language
they don't understand, they feel worse than left out: They actually suspect
that those speaking another language are making fun of or otherwise insulting
them. As a result, it's common for English-speaking supervisors with lots
of Spanish-speaking subordinates to demand that they speak English. But unless
there's a good business reason--such as safety concerns or the need
to speak to clients or customers in their own language--prohibiting employees
from speaking languages other than English should be a no-no. It's especially
important not to bar people from speaking their own languages on their own timeat
lunch or on breaks, for example.
In one class action complaint pending with the Equal Employment Opportunity
Commission (EEOC), retail store employees alleged they were forbidden to speak
Spanish among themselves, even in the lunchroomeven though their language
facility was valuable in making sales to wealthy South American customers. EEOC
has said the retailer's written policy on language falls within acceptable
guidelines, but it claims that individual managers ignored the policy and demanded
English from subordinates. Similar situations are common where a service employera
hospital, hotel, or restauranthires many recent immigrants into a variety
of low-skill jobs, such as mopping floors or cleaning guest rooms. In fact,
more than half of the Jack in the Box restaurant chain's employees are
Hispanic or Latino, as are a third of the employees of Chili's, Maggiano's
Little Italy, and Romano's Macaroni Grill.
What if hotel guests complain that groups of maids swirl around them chattering
in Spanish? Can you demand that workers either remain silent in the presence
of guests or speak only in English? Probably not, because it could be seen as
discriminatory. However, you can counsel them that guests who don't speak
Spanish could be offended, so they should keep their voices down and avoid extended
hallway conversations. An even better plan is to help them learn English by
subsidizing evening classes or providing them with in-house training. Becoming
fluently bilingual will help them succeed in earning better payand help
you be sure you're communicating effectively with your employees.
Tip: Cost-effective, self-paced, interactive training materials are
available. The contents are based on a learning system originally developed
for children aged 4 to 8. Each student of English uses a book, a cartridge,
and the learning system to learn common on-the-job words and phrases, usually
in about 4 months.