Leigh Branham isn't so much concerned with boosting retention
or reducing turnover in general. His focus is on "keeping the people who keep
you in business"--the title of one of his books (AMACOM, 2000). That is,
it's OK to lose poor performers, but it's not OK to lose those on whom your
organization depends.
For a Limited Time receive a
FREE HR Report "Top 10 Best Practices in HR Management." This comprehensive special report will give you the information you need to know about these current HR challenges and how to most effectively manage them in your workplace.
Download Now
Generational differences are key. Branham spoke at a recent Society for Human
Resource Management conference, titling his presentation "The Seven Hidden
Reasons Employees Leave: How to Recognize the Subtle Signs and Act Before It's
Too Late." That's the title of his latest book (AMACOM, 2005); he is founder
and principal of Kansas consulting firm Keeping the People.
Branham perceives big differences in employee attitudes
according to age. Dividing the workforce into Traditionals, Boomers, Xers, and
Millennials, he urges older managers to treat employees the way they were never
treated. That is, Traditionals and Boomers were likely given little feedback,
little training, and little career advice by their supervisors. Continual
feedback and continual learning, through both training and special assignments,
are crucial to younger workers--even more for Millennials than for Xers,
he believes. So if an organization wants to keep high performers, especially
younger ones, it must learn how to nurture them.
Branham points to a study in which both employees and
managers were asked why workers either quit or become disengaged. The majority
of managers--89 percent--said the problem is that such employees feel
they're underpaid. But only 12 percent of employees cited poor pay as what
turned them off. Says Branham, "HR knows why people leave, but managers clearly
don't, so they'll keep badgering HR to enhance compensation and benefits. And
that's not the problem."
Why do employees disengage? Branham's seven "hidden" reasons are these:
- The
job isn't what the employee expected (in fact, he says, 40 percent of turnover
happens in the first 6 months of work).
- The
job isn't a good fit for the employee's talents and interests.
- There
is little or no coaching or feedback from supervisors.
- The
employee sees no opportunities for advancement.
- The
employee feels devalued and disrespected.
- The
employee is overworked and overstressed. (This lack of work/life balance is the
top reason women quit or disengage.)
- The
employee doesn't trust management or the organization's leadership.
The younger workers are, the more important career
advancement will be to them. And although disrespect involves many kinds of
treatment, poor pay can be a factor in making employees believe that they are
not valued. To further illustrate his seven reasons, Branham asserts that all
working people have four basic on-the-job needs: to trust their employers, to
be appreciated for their work, to feel competent to do their jobs well, and to
have reasons to hope they have a future with the employer.
What can be done about disengagement? It's a serious problem: Only 25 percent of
employees are fully engaged, while 15 percent are actively disengaged. Sadly,
some employers believe that state of affairs can't be changed. They have what
Branham calls "a replacement mindset," in which turnover is acceptable as a
cost of doing business. In a "retention mindset," every "regrettable departure"
needs to be identified and understood.
Here are Branham's seven best practices to counter the
reasons people leave:
- Give
every candidate a realistic preview of the job, especially in high-turnover
positions such as bank tellers and call center employees. If necessary, arrange
for candidates to sit with an employee for a half day.
- Hire
for fit, and never hire in a hurry.
- Train
supervisors to provide timely, specific, and constructive feedback.
- Give
employees the tools and training to manage their own career paths, such as
encouragement to seek lateral transfers to different jobs.
- Continually
seek employee input; listen to it, and respond.
- Put
employee needs first and try to meet them. (Branham says if employers treated
their customers as badly as most do their employees, they'd be out of
business.)
- Adopt
an attitude of servant leadership, in which managers work to keep employees
happy, not vice versa.
For more from Branham, see his website, www.keepingthepeople.com.